Wesley Huff's Plagiarism and The Question of Christmas🎄
I stopped following Wes Huff years ago but even so, I could not help feeling a level of sadness over his recent plagiarism scandal. Sadly, all the apologetics work he has worked so hard for has suddenly been marked by dishonesty and trust has been broken. I loved his defense of the closed canon of scripture and his videos against the legitimacy of the book of Enoch. He truly is a gifted speaker but alas!
Wes Huff has admitted to plagiarism and is stepping away from ministry. I will be praying for him, for his wife and children, and for everyone who looked up to him.
Still, I believe he made the right call. Scripture holds teachers to a higher standard (James 3:1), and stepping down shows humility.
But his situation leaves many of us with a question. A lot of believers trusted his video "Christmas Isn't Pagan" because of who he was. So, in the same spirit of honesty and integrity we ask of every Bible teacher, let’s go back and test what he taught.
The Short Version
If you only have a minute, here's what I found:
- The early believers did not celebrate Messiah's birthday for about 300 years.
- Some "ancient proof" of an early Christmas turns out to be forged or added later.
- Scholars still disagree about why December 25 was chosen. It is not settled.
- Church leaders themselves admitted that sun worship crept into the holiday.
- Scripture already gives us Messiah's own appointed times.
Now let's walk through it together.

What Happened With Wes Huff
On November 8, biblical scholar Dan McClellan posted a video showing that Wes had used other scholars' work without giving them credit. More examples came out over the next few days. In one of his own videos, about 500 words were reportedly copied word for word from another scholar's article.
On November 18, Midwestern Seminary ended its partnership with him. On November 19, Wes admitted it, called it sin, and stepped back from ministry.
Why This Matters for Christmas
The real issue isn't the copying itself. It's the dishonesty underneath it. Plagiarism means presenting someone else's work as your own. For a teacher whose whole ministry rested on being trusted with the evidence, that's a matter of integrity, and Wes himself called it "sin".
That doesn't mean everything he taught was false. Truth is decided by the evidence, not by who says it. But many of us were told, "Just watch Wes Huff, he's done the research." We trusted his honesty with the sources. When that honesty is in question, it's wise to check those sources ourselves.
His Christmas video made three main claims. Let's test each one.
Claim 1: "Christians Celebrated December 25 First"
What the evidence shows: There's no clear record of believers celebrating Messiah's birth on any date before the 300s.
A few early writers did try to figure out when Yeshua was born. Most copies of a work by Hippolytus (around A.D. 204) give December 25. But the oldest copy has a confusing second date in late March or early April next to it, and another copy gives no date at all. Many scholars believe December 25 was added later by a copyist, though some disagree. But others came up with very different dates. Around A.D. 200, Clement of Alexandria wrote that some people placed the birth in the spring, around April 19 or 20, or May 20. In A.D. 243, another writing placed it on March 28.
These were guesses on paper, not celebrations. Figuring out a date isn't the same as holding a whole feast.

Claim 2: "Ancient Documents Prove an Early Christmas"
What the evidence shows: Some of the documents people point to don't hold up.
- The Letter of Theophilus claims to be from the 100s, but scholars widely see it as a forgery or at best fictional dialogue from around A.D. 600. (Bibliotheca Sacra, Roger Pearse)
- The Didascalia has a line about a January feast that appears to have been added later. (History of Epiphany)
- The Liber Pontificalis is a book from the Middle Ages, not a reliable record of the early church. (Liber Pontificalis overview, Loomis translation)

Claim 3: "Pagans Copied the Christians' Date"
What the evidence shows: Scholars honestly disagree, so this can't be called settled.
Here's the most important thing we know for sure:
The earliest record of Christmas on December 25 and the earliest record of the Roman sun feast on December 25 appear together, in the very same document.
It's a Roman almanac made in A.D. 354. One section lists Christ's birth in Bethlehem on December 25. Another section lists December 25 as the "birthday of the Unconquered," celebrated with chariot races. Most historians understand "the Unconquered" to mean Sol Invictus, the sun god.
Historians think the Christmas list may go back to around A.D. 336, and some think the sun feast is older too. But in writing, they first show up side by side. So no one can honestly say the evidence proves Christians had the date first.
Wes's view didn't start with him. Some respected historians hold it. But plenty see it differently:
- Susan Roll, who wrote a major study on the origins of Christmas, keeps the question of pagan influence open. (Roll's book, Biblical Archaeology Society)
- Martin Wallraff, who studied sun imagery in the early church, believed Christmas and the sun festival grew up side by side. (Church History journal)
- David Gwynn, a historian at Royal Holloway, University of London, has said Christmas may have been meant to replace the Sol Invictus sun festival. (History Today)
To be fair, none of these scholars were responding to Wes himself. But their work shows his view is one side of a real debate.

What Church Leaders Admitted
We don't have to guess whether pagan customs mixed into the day. Church leaders said so themselves.
- Augustine (around A.D. 400) told his church not to celebrate the day for the sun, as pagans did, but for the One who made the sun.
- Leo the Great (around A.D. 450) scolded Christians who bowed to the rising sun on the steps of St. Peter's before going in to worship. He also warned that some Christians thought Christmas was honoring the "rising of the new sun" rather than the birth of Messiah. (Sermon 22, chapter 6; Sermon 27, chapter 4)
- Gregory the Great (A.D. 597) told missionaries not to tear down pagan temples, but to turn them into churches and give old customs a Christian use. (clearly some syncretism going on here 🤨)
These men weren't against Christmas. And they still had to warn their people about pagan sun worship creeping into their Christmas holiday celebrations!
What Scripture Says
For our family, the history is only part of it. Scripture already tells us how the Lord wants to be worshiped:
"Take heed to thyself that thou be not snared by following them... and that thou inquire not after their gods, saying, How did these nations serve their gods? even so will I do likewise. Thou shalt not do so unto the LORD thy God." (Deuteronomy 12:30-31)
He has given us His appointed times in Leviticus 23. We don't need to borrow a date from Rome or guess Jesus's bday to declare a feast when our Father already gave us His own festival calendar. That's one of the sweetest parts of teaching my kids the feasts. They're His, and they all point to Messiah.
Be a Berean, Mama
This is a reminder for all of us. No teacher, however popular, takes the place of opening the Word and checking things for ourselves, like the Bereans did (Acts 17:11).
"Prove all things; hold fast that which is good." (1 Thessalonians 5:21)